What if some of the things we think are simply who we are began as conclusions drawn under circumstances we barely remember?
When I first began writing this essay, I had recently begun learning to play pickleball.
Which seems simple enough, right?
I was a beginner, as were many others in the group. The class had been advertised as “beginner friendly,” although my first impression was that everyone was already better than me. The instructor was filling in at the last minute. He was not terrible, but he was noticeably irritated, and he was not particularly warm with a group of people who were there to learn.
At one point, another woman even softly said, “I thought this was supposed to be fun.”
I understood exactly what she meant.
I felt nervous. So nervous.
It takes me some time to warm up to new things, particularly when I am learning something I have never done before. I was trying to figure out where to stand, how to hold the paddle, where the ball was going, and what I was supposed to be doing, all while keenly aware of how much less competent I felt than everyone else seemed to feel.
I found myself paying as much attention to other people’s reactions as I was to the game itself. Every one of my mistakes felt illuminated. If I hit the ball poorly or missed an easy shot, I was suddenly aware of everyone around me, as though they were noticing it far more than they actually were.
That night, I felt like crying. In truth, there were moments during the lesson when I could have cried on the court itself.
What surprised me was not the nervousness itself. It was what returned with it.
I suddenly remembered being in third grade and playing softball for the first, and as it turned out, the last time.
I wore the team’s requisite hideous orange baseball cap. I remember the softball looking enormous. I was afraid of it, and then got bonked in the head by it anyway. Hard. I remember an important adult in my life hollering at me. More than anything, I remember feeling awkward, foolish, and exposed. I did not know what I was doing and I was afraid of getting it wrong.
I had not thought about that experience in years.
Maybe decades.
And yet, standing on a pickleball court as an adult, something about the combination of being inexperienced, being watched, trying to perform something I did not yet know how to do, and being instructed by an agitated adult brought that memory surprisingly into focus.
Not literally. I knew exactly where I was.
But emotionally, something dormant had been awakened.
That distinction is important to me.
I am not interested in turning every difficult experience into trauma. I have watched the word become so broadly used that sometimes it seems to explain everything and therefore very little.
What happened on that pickleball court was not some catastrophic event.
It was a beginner’s pickleball class.
The instructor was irritated. I was inexperienced and I struggled. In reality, so were many of the others there that evening.
And somehow, that was enough to bring back something I hadn’t realized was still there.
It also made me reconsider something else.
I have never really played sports.
I’d never considered that much. I participated in cheer and then drill team for several years, but I never developed an interest in playing sports. I had simply come to think of myself as someone who did not play them.
Now I wonder whether there was more to that than I realized.
Maybe the third grade experience did not determine anything about the rest of my life. I cannot know that.
But perhaps something was learned there.
For some of us, experiences that combine being inexperienced and watched, the fear of making mistakes, and pressure from an irritated adult may leave impressions that are no longer accessible to conscious memory but continue to influence us.
It is doubtful that we always remember the conclusions we drew when we were young.
Sometimes we simply live according to them.
About The Author
Cheryl Strain
I offer in-person therapy in Houston and work best with people who value depth and a thoughtful, collaborative process. If you are interested in exploring whether working together feels like a good fit, I invite you to get in touch. We can take the next step at a pace that feels right for you.
